Seminarians

Theology School Provides Broad Base of Knowledge for Ministers

Theological education provides a broad base of knowledge for ministers. Most seminarians are enrolled in the Master of Divinity (M.Div.) program. This curriculum includes study of the Bible, theology, church history, ethics, and practical skills for ministry such as preaching, pastoral care, and Christian education. Some schools offer Greek and/or Hebrew. A Master of Divinity degree requires three to four years to complete, depending on the structure of the particular school’s program.

The Association of Theological Schools is the most widely recognized accrediting agency for theological institutions. Schools may be divinity schools, which are parts of universities or seminaries, which are free-standing and usually associated with a particular denomination.

In addition, the University Senate of The United Methodist Church approves graduate theological schools. Criteria used to approve the schools include institutional integrity, well-structured programs, clearly defined church relationships, and strong management. These schools also must also affirm an “Education Covenant for Partnership” from the 2000 General Conference.

Quality of Leadership

Seminaries are committed to educating quality leaders for the church. Rigorous academics, along with care for spiritual formation and community service are all geared toward building quality of character and quality of leadership.

Understanding of Call

Even after enrollment in seminary, the need to question and clarify a call continues. God moves and guides people — sometimes through professors, sometimes through course work, sometimes through friendships – in the faith community at seminary. It’s important to take advantage of all the learning experiences offered at a seminary — both those in the classroom and those outside it.

Financial Implications of a Seminary Education

A seminary education can be expensive. Recruiting the best students to lead the church requires substantial financial support from the church. The General Board of Higher Education and Ministry has added an additional $1 million to its Special Seminary Scholarship Fund to provide scholarships for seminarians under age 35. Other loans and scholarships are also available through the Board’s Office of Loans and Scholarships.

The Ministerial Education Fund is a critical piece of the denomination’s financial investment in leadership. It represents the church’s affirmation that it shares the responsibility for education of clergy. Seminary students need the support of their annual conferences and congregations, plus help from the MEF — a critical part of the circle of support for ministry. For most of our seminaries, MEF support represents between 12 percent and 20 percent of their annual budget – a big piece of keeping tuition and other costs lower for the clergy we need. Twenty-five percent of the MEF money stays in the annual conferences to provide scholarships to seminarians.

Political Science, Art History Abandoned for Ministry

Moonyoung Lee says no one was more surprised than she was when she answered the call to ministry.

“During my undergraduate years I had been a political science major, and after graduation I decided I’d pursue a degree and work as an art historian. Instead, I ended up at Claremont School of Theology. No one was more surprised than I!”

Lee quickly discovered that she loved seminary. “From the first, I enjoyed the challenge of my classes. To use my mind this way was exciting, and I kept discovering new things about myself. Also, even though I was born in Korea and spent nine years there as a child, I had grown up in Claremont [a suburb of Los Angeles], where there was not much diversity. When I got to Claremont School of Theology, I discovered the most diverse place I had ever been. I grew as the result of being with people ‘different’ from me — geographically, such as those from the Midwest and the Northeast, but also ethnically — African Americans, other Asians, Hispanics. It was a rich experience, both inside and outside the classroom,” she said.

She also had her first ministry experience after starting seminary. She was hired as children’s minister at a church . . . and quickly decided this was not for her. She knew nothing about ministry with children and thought everything was going wrong. Deciding she was “not cut out for this,” Lee was about to quit when she got a message — a quiet, strong message — during her prayer time one day: “Why are you so worried? Of course you do not know everything. Don’t you realize that this is your time to learn?”

“After that, I did understand. I think my call is something like Balaam and his donkey. The donkey tried three times to convince Balaam something important was happening, but Balaam didn’t get it. I think it took God several attempts to get through to me, too. The experience of God’s calling me taught me one important thing: We are not pieces of puzzles to be somehow fit together. We are clay, pliant and ever ready to be molded, all our lives.”

For Lee, seminary has been a rich time, a challenging time, and a time of pure pleasure in learning. “I am so grateful that I responded to the call to go to seminary. It has been an exciting way for God to continue molding me.

Academic disciplines — biblical studies, philosophy, languages, ethics, history, and theology — form a major part of the core graduate study curriculum. But theological schools also teach practical skills for ministry in the church and in society. Both theological and professional skills are needed in order to be an effective pastor.

The Master of Divinity is the most common seminary degree. But other graduate degrees may be more appropriate for your ministry. For instance, if you want to teach in a seminary or college, you will need a Ph.D. If you want to work with the homeless, you may want a Master of Social Work. If you want to work in Christian education, that’s the master’s degree you’ll want.

Seminaries have distinctive approaches to spiritual formation. But each carries the understanding that attention to spiritual growth is an important part of theological education. The ways in which these needs are addressed vary from seminary to seminary — some offer Covenant Discipleship Groups, some provide spiritual direction, and all have an orientation toward community in which faith is strengthened and challenged.

Overall, when most Protestant denominations are included, statistics show that about 50 percent enter local church ministry. In a recent survey of United Methodist seminary graduates, about 70 percent indicated they would be serving in local churches. This was down from 90 percent in 1970.

A theological education can be a jumping off place for pursuing other vocations. For instance, Thomas M. Chappell, co-founder of the Tom’s of Maine line of soap and toothpaste, completed Harvard Divinity School. Al Gore attended Vanderbilt Divinity School before switching to law. A theological degree can be a path to social work, to academic teaching, to becoming a financial adviser for socially-responsible investing, or to a career in writing.

Estimates showed that more than half of spring 2002 graduates went to their first appointment with personal debt. Of these, half expected their debt to be $15,000. And another one-third would be more than $25,000 in debt. While amount of debt for a seminary student is decidedly less than for a student graduating from law or medical school, seminary graduates usually earn less upon graduation. This makes the debt load of a seminary graduate more significant in the process of making a decision about graduate school.

Financial aid and scholarship are available from individual theology schools. In addition, the General Board of Higher Education and Ministry’s Office of Loans and Scholarships has many programs available for undergraduates as well as graduate students preparing for ministry. The Board supports a Special Seminary Scholarship Fund and administers the Ministerial Education Fund. Support is often available at the congregational and annual conference level. All of these are critical parts of the financial support system for seminarians.

This may or may not be a good idea. If you work at a church, the hours specified are often not actually enough to do a good job, and sometimes extra, unpaid duties arise, which translate into extra work hours for you. Protecting quality time to give to your seminary studies is an important thing to remember as you consider employment.

Supported by The United Methodist Church, the Young Adult Seminarians Network was founded in 2004 for seminarians under the age of 35. YASN works to support seminarians in being advocates for justice, having an active voice and role within The United Methodist Church, and helping people discern their vocations. In addition, YASN seeks to support and help people navigate through the candidacy process and to provide a safe community in which issues relating to ministry as young adults can be addressed. Their Web address is www.yasn.org.

Seminary Enrollment Up, Fewer Graduates Enter Local Church Ministry

The church faces major challenges in educating its leaders. And John Wesley’s vision of a disciplined, educated clergy is at stake.

Enrollment is up at Protestant seminaries, but a shrinking portion of these graduates will enter local church ministry. According to the Rev. Daniel O. Aleshire of the Association of Theological Schools in the U.S. and Canada, only about half of those graduating with a Master of Divinity degree now enter parish ministry. And, he says, that percent has dropped sharply in just one generation. This challenge — to form and maintain disciplined and educated clergy leadership for the church — is among the first that must be addressed.

Another challenge is financial. A seminary education is expensive. Most seminaries are tuition driven. That is, they are dependent in large part for their existence on tuition to fund their budgets, pay their staff and professors, and maintain their buildings.

The United Methodist Church has to decide if it is willing to invest in its seminaries to a point that truly lessens the financial dependence on tuition. This would dictate a major investment by the denomination. The church must also consider whether it is willing to invest financially in seminarians themselves to lessen the costly burden of their education. Right now, the Ministerial Education Fund is the main way the denomination supports seminaries. MEF support represents between 12 percent and 20 percent of the annual budget of seminaries.

The curriculum of theological schools — what is taught and how it is taught — is another issue.

“The church is asking much more of seminaries than these schools are capable of sustaining,” says the Rev. Mary Ann Moman, associate general secretary of the Division of Ordained Ministry, General Board of Higher Education and Ministry. Annual conferences are increasing the educational requirements for ministry candidates, reducing the seminaries’ ability to provide more in-depth, advanced courses. “We need to find a balance, to decide what we need most from pastoral leadership. The practical part of theological education is important. But so is in-depth knowledge of the Bible, church history, and ethics. These two sometimes represent competing claims on the curriculum, and we need to be careful as we sort these out.

“All these challenges seem daunting, but I believe that we as a church can address them,” said Moman. “And, I believe we must.”

Steps Into Seminary

If you are interested in exploring and learning more about a theological education and ministry, there are several things you can do. The Fund for Theological Education, along with the General Board of Higher Education and Ministry, recommend these:

  • Talk with your local church pastor, your campus minister or chaplain, or someone else whose faith and life you admire. Tell them that you’re thinking about seminary and ministry. Share your dreams with them and tell them your fears or hesitations. Conversations and prayer with these people can be a source of guidance and direction.
  • You will find many helpful resources on this Web site. Also, you may want to visit other Web sites – some sponsored by the denomination, some funded by other organizations – that address issues of call, vocation, and seminary. These include
  • Contact an admissions counselor at a theological school. There will be someone in the admissions office trained to answer your questions about ministry. Many seminaries offer events on campus when you can learn more about theological education by visiting classes and talking with current students. For a list of United Methodist theological schools approved by the University Senate, click here. For a list of non-United Methodist theological schools approved by the University Senate, click here.
  • Search out some hands-on experience. There are many church-related internships and programs especially for people to participate actively in ministry and then have an opportunity to reflect on it. Explore Ministry’s Web site has an area listing several of the organizations.